You are here
Evaluators: Are we still the Bad Guys?
“Evaluator;” say it five times in the mirror and a guy will appear behind you armed with survey questions and a red pen, ready to criticize your life’s work. It’s just like your favorite childhood horror stories imagined.
Despite our best efforts (and a definite improvement!), it appears that we live in a world where program staff are the heroes, we are the villains trying to undo their work. Evaluators are the bad guys.
After the first day of Evaluation 2016, I kept thinking about John Gargani’s remark that “evaluation is the largest profession that no one has ever heard of” to a room of 1000 evaluation professionals from across the globe. There’s an irony to it but it was immediately affirmed when a member of staff at the conference asked me, “what is an evaluator?” In addition to the beautiful comedic timing, this question also highlights two of the main obstacles to evaluation becoming a cornerstone of good practice; visibility & understanding.
Fundamentally, our goal is to create more effective programming. We want to make sure that we can learn from our failures, our successes and move forward. The issue comes in our ability to communicate the value of Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) to those who don’t consider themselves M&E professionals. There’s a fear of the unknown when it comes to M&E. These are not new issues, but as a field we are moving towards new solutions. How can we design a more inclusive M&E? How can we thoughtfully and meaningfully address the fear of the unknown so that evaluators are no longer bogeymen (and women!) but partners in continuing improvement?
This falls on us. It’s our role to show the importance of effective monitoring and evaluation. It’s our role to demonstrate the value of effective monitoring and evaluation through helping to establish better programming. Let's be clear, we are making progress and the growth in both adaptive management and developmental evaluation shows that we are moving in the right direction but we still have a long way to go.
AEA is tackling these issues with new vigor this week, and DME for Peace will be continuing these conversations this winter as we host The Breaking Barriers in Participation & Inclusion in Peacebuilding Evaluation Conference in Cape Town. And who knows, maybe someday soon we’ll get to be the good guys we all aim to be.
Be sure to follow @DMEforPeace on Twitter for live updates throughout the conference!